SI joint pain or lower back pain? How to tell the difference
This is the hard part. SI joint pain looks a lot like other low back pain 1,2, and the usual tools don't settle it cleanly.
A careful history and examination come first, to rule out look-alikes 2. Three or more positive pain-provocation tests point towards the SI joint 2. But those tests are better at ruling it out than confirming it. If they're negative, the SI joint is very unlikely to be the problem. If they're positive, it's a strong lead, not a verdict 2. Scans are of limited help for this kind of pain 2. A local anaesthetic injection into the joint, done by a doctor, is the closest thing to confirmation 1,2.
There's also a trap worth knowing about. Research suggests pain in the SI region is often referred from the spine above it, yet a review of 43 treatment trials found 74% never checked the spine before diagnosing SI joint pain 6. So we check your back first. Stiffness that bites when you arch backwards may point to facet joint pain. Pain travelling down the leg with numbness, tingling or weakness points more to a nerve in the spine 2 and is worth ruling out as sciatica.