Need urgent care? 24/7 Mobile & After-Hours Emergency Physiotherapy Call (02) 8111 5633 For life-threatening emergencies, always call 000
Hand

Scaphoid Fracture

5.0 average rating on Google
Registered NDIS Provider
SIRA Registered Provider

You put a hand out to break a fall: off a bike, off a wet step, off the back of a tackle. The wrist swelled a little but you could still move it, so you called it a sprain. Weeks later there's still a deep ache on the thumb side whenever you grip something.

That's how most scaphoid fractures go unnoticed. Why it's treated so carefully has almost nothing to do with how much it hurts.

What's actually causing it

The scaphoid sits at the base of your thumb, in the row of small bones linking your hand to your forearm. Land on an outstretched hand and the force travels straight through it. For most cases, that's the whole mechanism 2.

What sets it apart is where the blood comes from. Blood enters the scaphoid at the end closest to your thumb and runs backwards toward your forearm 6, so everything upstream of a break is fed through the break. About two-thirds of these fractures happen at the narrow waist 5, the worst possible place.

NHS patient guidance states the consequence plainly: a waist fracture affecting the blood supply "can stop oxygen and nutrients reaching the bone," causing "slow healing (delayed union) or no healing (non-union)," and if it's cut off completely, "part of the bone can die (avascular necrosis)." Those complications "can cause continued pain, impairment of wrist function and early arthritis" 1.

So a wrist gets immobilised on suspicion: where the broken pieces stay close together "a fracture line is not visible on x-rays" 1, and repeat X-rays are deliberately delayed because the bone changes "may only become visible at that time or later" 2.

Wrist and hand bones showing a fracture line across the scaphoid bone at the base of the thumb

Scaphoid fracture, or just a sprain? How to tell the difference

The catch is that you can usually still move your wrist. The pain is often not severe, and it's worse with gripping and pinching 6. Retained movement is why this gets written off as a sprain, and it rules nothing out. Nor can you check it yourself: "the scaphoid bone is not simple to examine and without specialist training you will be unable to check it for yourself" 2.

Three clinical tests are commonly used, and what they can't do matters as much as what they can:

  • Anatomical snuffbox tenderness: about 86% sensitive, but only about 30% specific 3
  • Scaphoid tubercle tenderness: the most accurate of the three, at around 95% sensitivity and 74% specificity 3
  • Scaphoid compression test: the weakest, at about 43% sensitivity and 29.6% specificity 3

They're good at raising suspicion and poor at confirming, which is why imaging and precautionary immobilisation follow instead of a confident "it's just a sprain."

The same fall can also produce a distal radius fracture, another fracture or dislocation in the wrist 6, or a scapholunate ligament injury 5. If yours came on gradually instead, the Hand section of our Injury Finder covers conditions that fit better.

How it's diagnosed

A suspected scaphoid fracture follows a set pathway, and a clear first X-ray doesn't end it. Your clinician asks how the injury happened, then checks for tenderness directly over the scaphoid, along with swelling, bruising and lost movement 6. X-rays come next.

If the wrist is tender over the scaphoid but nothing shows, it's splinted and you're brought back, typically 10 to 14 days later, to be re-examined and to decide whether another X-ray is needed 2. Still suspected at that review? An MRI is arranged, or a CT scan when MRI isn't suitable 1.

How we treat it

The scans, splint, cast and any decision about surgery belong to your emergency department, GP or orthopaedic team, not to us. What we do is everything after: rebuilding a wrist, hand and arm immobilised for six weeks or more. That follows a clear order 10:

  • Restoring movement first: active and active-assisted range for the wrist and thumb, plus the fingers, elbow and shoulder, which all stiffen in a cast and get forgotten. Swelling is settled alongside this, not waited out.
  • Hands-on joint work: mobilisations to the radio-carpal, radio-ulnar and carpal joints when range doesn't return with exercise alone.
  • Rebuilding grip and wrist strength: the step most often skipped. Even with therapy, some people don't get back the range and strength they had before the injury 6.
  • Back to the actual task: the grip you need for work, the load you need for sport, built around your goals rather than a generic timeline.

To be upfront, there's no trial-level evidence for this sequence specifically: a literature search returned nothing at that level. It reflects established NHS rehabilitation advice 10, which is a reasonable basis for treatment but isn't a randomised trial, and we won't pretend otherwise.

Other treatments we may use

Activity modification during the splinted phase.

NHS patient guidance is direct: keep the splint on except for washing, elevate the arm, take simple painkillers as needed, and keep moving every joint that isn't splinted. No driving, no manual work, no sport or gym 1,2.

Casting and splinting: not our decision, and not settled science.

A splint or cast is the usual choice where a fracture is suspected but X-rays are negative 6. Beyond that the evidence is unresolved: on long-arm versus short-arm casts, and on including the thumb at all, a pooled review of randomised trials found no evidence to favour one method 11. Anyone claiming one correct splint is ahead of the research.

Further imaging.

If a fracture is still suspected at review, an MRI is usually arranged, with CT where MRI isn't suitable 1. MRI is the strongest option (94.2% sensitivity, 97.7% specificity); CT is less conclusive than people assume, at 81.5% sensitivity "only slightly better than X-ray"; ultrasound is weaker again, around 77.4% specificity 3.

Surgery.

Intuition says a screw fixes it faster; the best available trial says otherwise. In 439 adults with a waist fracture displaced by 2mm or less, early fixation produced no significant difference in wrist scores at 52 weeks compared with casting (p=0.27). More in the surgery group had a potentially serious complication (14% versus 1%), though fewer had cast-related complications (2% versus 18%) 4. Return to sport is where it does have an edge: across 11 studies of athletes, an average of about 7 weeks after surgery against about 10 weeks with casting 9. It's a real option, decided by an orthopaedic surgeon, not the default better one.

Your recovery path: Reset, Rebuild, Return

A scaphoid fracture follows The Well Motion Recovery Path™ but your fracture team runs the first phase. You move up when the bone and the wrist are ready, not on a date.

  • Reset: the splint or cast, or the weeks after surgery. Your ED, GP or orthopaedic team runs it. Keep every joint outside the splint moving 1,2. Expect a stiff, weak wrist when the cast comes off. You move on when your doctor clears the fracture.
  • Rebuild: where we start. Wrist and thumb movement first, hands-on joint work if range stalls, then grip and wrist strength 10. Expect movement back before strength. We move you on when the hand does what your daily tasks ask of it.
  • Return: the grip your job needs, or the load your sport puts through the wrist. We test those tasks at the weight and speed you use them. You leave with a strength program.

How long it usually takes. About 90% of waist fractures that have not shifted unite after 6 weeks in a cast 5. Fractures nearer the thumb need 4 to 6 weeks, moderately displaced waist fractures 8 to 10 5. Across 11 studies of athletes, return to sport averaged about 7 weeks after surgery and 10 with a cast 9. Rehabilitation after the cast has not been timed in trials, so we give no number for it.

Reducing the risk of it happening again

Two things have been measured here: what protects a wrist in a fall, and what gets in the way of this bone healing.

  • Wear wrist guards for board and skate sports. Pooled studies of snowboarders found wrist fractures were about 70% less likely in riders wearing guards 7. That figure is for wrist fractures of all kinds. Nobody has counted scaphoid fractures separately. Guards are advised for inline skating and skateboarding too 6.
  • Smoking counts against healing. A 2025 review of four studies of fresh scaphoid fractures found smokers were about 1.7 times as likely to end up with a bone that didn't unite 8.
  • Stay out of sport and the gym until you're cleared. While a fracture is suspected, the advice is no sport, no gym and no manual work with the injured hand 1.
  • Keep the splint on and keep your review. Wear it day and night, taking it off only to wash 2, until your scan results have been discussed with you 1.

When to get it checked properly

If you've fallen onto an outstretched hand and have pain on the thumb side of your wrist, get it assessed, the same day if you can. Don't let a normal X-ray end the conversation.

Book an assessment, or go back to whoever assessed you, if:

  • your wrist is still tender on the thumb side a week or two after a fall, even with a clear X-ray
  • you were told to come back for a review or repeat imaging and haven't yet
  • gripping, pinching or twisting still hurts weeks after the injury
  • movement, grip or thumb use hasn't recovered since your cast came off

None of that means something has gone wrong. Most scaphoid fractures heal, and for minimally displaced waist fractures a cast performs as well as surgery at a year 4. The mistake is assuming a clear first X-ray settles it.

Your first appointment

We start by listening: how it began, what makes it worse, and what it's stopping you from doing. Then we examine the area, explain what we find in plain English, and agree a plan with you. Your first visit is 40 minutes at Engadine and 30 minutes at our other clinics.

We see patients at Engadine, Mount Annan, Narellan and Appin, and at home through our mobile physiotherapy service. If you have private health cover, here's how health fund rebates work for physiotherapy.

FAQs

Can you have a scaphoid fracture and not know it?

Yes, common enough to be the main reason this injury is handled so cautiously. Around 21.8% of scaphoid fractures are occult on initial four-view X-rays 3, and one may not become obvious until roughly 10 to 14 days after the injury; even then it might not show 2. Because you can often still move the wrist, it gets mistaken for a sprain, and prompt diagnosis is what helps avoid non-union 3.

How serious is a broken scaphoid?

Serious because of where it is, not how much it hurts. A fracture at the narrow waist can disrupt the blood supply, risking delayed union, non-union or avascular necrosis, which "can cause continued pain, impairment of wrist function and early arthritis" 1. Non-union rates as high as 12% have been reported 3. Managed properly, most heal fine.

Do you need a cast for scaphoid fracture?

For most minimally displaced waist fractures, casting is the recommended first-line treatment, not a lesser alternative to surgery. The SWIFFT trial found no significant difference in wrist scores at 52 weeks between early surgery and casting, concluding that adults with waist fractures displaced by 2mm or less "should have initial cast immobilisation," with surgery reserved for confirmed non-union 4. A suspected fracture is usually splinted before that, until it can be reassessed 1. Either way it's your treating doctor's call, not a physiotherapist's.

How long does it take for a scaphoid injury to heal?

About 90% of waist fractures that haven't shifted unite after six weeks in a cast, checked with a scan at that point 5. Beyond that the timeline tracks where the break is and how far it has moved: fractures nearer the thumb need the shortest spell in a cast, around 4 to 6 weeks, and moderately displaced waist fractures need 8 to 10 weeks 5. The cast coming off is the start of recovery, not the end.

Can I drive with a scaphoid fracture?

Not while a suspected fracture is splinted: NHS patient guidance lists it plainly, alongside no manual work and no sport 1. Past that stage it depends on your injury and how the hand is functioning, so ask the team managing your fracture rather than a number you've read somewhere.

More Hand conditions

Hand

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

Numbness, tingling or pins and needles through your thumb, index and middle fingers, often worst overnight. It's a nerve compressed at the wrist, and there's usually plenty worth trying before surgery comes up.

Read more
Hand

Wrist Sprain

A wrist sprain means a ligament, one of the tough bands holding your wrist bones together, has been stretched or torn. It usually happens during sport, a sudden movement or a fall

Read more
Hand

Trigger Finger

Trigger finger is a finger or thumb that catches, gets stuck bent, or straightens with a click or snap

Read more
Hand

Ganglion Cyst (Wrist)

A ganglion cyst is a benign (non-cancerous) collection of fluid on a joint or tendon. It's the most common lump on the hand, usually on the back of the hand or wrist

Read more

If your cast has come off and your wrist still isn't doing what you need, that's the gap worth closing.

Book an assessment, or read more about our Fracture Clinic and Hand Rehabilitation.

Book an Assessment
Ahmed Elsayed, Principal Physiotherapist
Reviewed by Ahmed Elsayed Principal Physiotherapist at Well Motion

References

  1. Suspected Scaphoid Fracture Advice. Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust. https://www.leedsth.nhs.uk/patients/resources/suspected-scaphoid-fracture-advice/
  2. Suspected scaphoid injury. Wirral Community Health and Care NHS Foundation Trust. Last reviewed 27 January 2025. https://www.wchc.nhs.uk/resources/suspected-scaphoid-injury/
  3. Systematic Review of Diagnosis of Clinically Suspected Scaphoid Fractures. PMC7000269. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7000269/
  4. Dias JJ, et al. Surgical fixation compared with cast immobilisation for adults with a bicortical fracture of the scaphoid waist (SWIFFT): a pragmatic, multicentre, open-label, randomised superiority trial. The Lancet 2020;396(10248):390-401. PMID 32771106. Retrieved via PubMed. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30931-4: with its companion economic evaluation, Bone & Joint Journal 2021. PMID 34192942. https://doi.org/10.1302/0301-620X.103B7.BJJ-2020-2322.R2
  5. Clementson M, Björkman A, Thomsen NOB. Acute scaphoid fractures: guidelines for diagnosis and treatment. EFORT Open Reviews, 2020;5(2):96-103. PMID 32175096. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7047900/
  6. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Scaphoid Fracture of the Wrist. OrthoInfo. https://www.orthoinfo.org/en/diseases--conditions/scaphoid-fracture-of-the-wrist/
  7. Russell K, Hagel B, Francescutti LH. The effect of wrist guards on wrist and arm injuries among snowboarders: a systematic review. Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine, 2007;17(2):145-50. PMID 17414485. https://doi.org/10.1097/JSM.0b013e31803f901b
  8. Mistry D, Poole H, Jordan R, Shyamalan G. The effects of smoking on the management of scaphoid acute fractures and non-unions: a systematic review. European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Traumatology, 2025;36(1):8. PMID 41205085. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00590-025-04570-4
  9. Goffin JS, Liao Q, Robertson GA. Return to sport following scaphoid fractures: a systematic review and meta-analysis. World Journal of Orthopedics, 2019;10(2):101-114. PMID 30788227. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6379737/
  10. Scaphoid Fracture: Information for Patients (document STHK1109). Mersey and West Lancashire Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust. https://sthk.merseywestlancs.nhs.uk/media/.leaflets/606ef040ca7415.36926780.pdf
  11. Doornberg JN, Buijze GA, Ham SJ, Ring D, Bhandari M, Poolman RW. Nonoperative treatment for acute scaphoid fractures: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. The Journal of Trauma, 2011;71(4):1073-1081. PMID 21986747. Retrieved from PubMed. https://doi.org/10.1097/TA.0b013e318222f485